Contributors
Links
- Irish Aires Home Page
- Irish Aires Current Events
- Irish Aires Houston Links
- Irish Aires Links Page
- Irish Aires Archived
- Irish Aires Email Lists
- Irish Aires News Blog
Archives
This site includes the postings from the Irish Aires email list. This includes a listing of Irish/Celtic events in the Houston area and other information that the Irish Aires radio program posts.
Monday, November 06, 2006
Report Reveals Collusion in Loyalist Murders
(Poster's Note: The following was widely reported by
the news media this morning. Jay)
Report Reveals Collusion in Loyalist Murders
Members of the RUC and UDR colluded with loyalist
paramilitaries in 74 murders in the 1970s, according to an
international panel of legal experts.
The four-strong team examined 76 killings between 1972 and
1977 and said there was evidence of collusion in all but
two of the cases.
It said some senior officers knew of the crimes but "failed
to act to prevent or punish" those responsible.
While the international panel welcomed reforms introduced
by the British government to investigate the controversial
murders, they claimed they were still insufficient for
getting to the heart of collusion cases.
Northern Ireland`s police ombudsman Nuala O`Loan, they
said, did not have the powers to investigate collusion
involving members of the UDR.
The £30 million Historical Enquiries Team, set up by Police
Service of Northern Ireland chief constable Sir Hugh Orde,
also fell short of international standards for
investigations.
The panel called for:
:: Investigations by an independent team into allegations
of collusion in murders and attempted murders by loyalists,
capable of identifying those involved, examining how high
up the chain of command it went and focusing not just on
RUC and UDR involvement but also British Army and
intelligence agencies;
:: Investigations into murders carried out by republican
groups;
:: Full co-operation by paramilitary groups on both sides
with credible official investigations into collusion;
:: The publishing of the findings of all investigations,
including those by the Historical Enquiries Team which
currently plans only to share its findings with victims`
families;
:: The state to acknowledge publicly its responsibility in
sectarian killings where collusion is established;
:: Public apologies from senior officials to the families
of victims of collusion.
In their 115-page report, the panel said today:
"Credible evidence indicates that superiors of violent
extremist officers and agents, at least within the RUC,
were aware of their sectarian crimes yet failed to act to
prevent, investigate or punish them.
"On the contrary, they allegedly made statements that
appeared to condone participation in these crimes.
"Even after Weir and another officer confessed in 1978 -
information that should have blown the lid off RUC and
Ulster Defence Regiment involvement in murdering Catholics
- police investigations and ensuing prosecutions were
inadequate by any reasonable standard.
"As early as 1973, senior officials of the United Kingdom
were put on notice of the danger - and indeed some of the
facts - of sectarian violence by UDR soldiers using stolen
UDR weapons and ammunition, and supported by UDR training
and information.
"At least by 1975, senior officials were also informed that
some RUC police officers were `very close` to extremist
paramilitaries."
"There were also allegations by at least one former RUC man
that the Garda, the police force of the Republic of
Ireland, was not co-operative in bringing fugitives who
fled across the border to justice," the report said.
Communications from one local station to another across the
border, he said, had to be routed through Belfast and
Dublin.
"Technicalities were seized upon to deny extradition. Known
criminals were allowed to roam freely on the other side of
the border.
"The panel has had its hands full examining and documenting
the responsibility of the British state. It is in no
position to take on the vast additional assignment of
examining the possible responsibility of another state.
"However, the panel will bring these allegations to the
attention of the Irish authorities and suggest they deserve
to be looked into."
The British government told the panel it would be
inappropriate to comment as the murders were already the
subject of inquiries by a number of agencies.
These included the European Court of Human Rights, the
Historical Enquiries Team, and the Police Ombudsman.
The panel was convened two years ago at the request of the
Pat Finucane Centre.
Among the controversial murders they investigated were:
:: The killing of 23-year-old single bricklayer Patrick
Connolly on October 4 1972 in a grenade attack on his
Portadown home by the Ulster Volunteer Force, also injuring
his mother and brother;
:: The double murder by the UVF of 46-year-old Catholic
Department of the Environment employee Patrick Molloy and
49-year-old Protestant Orange Order member Jack Wylie in a
bomb attack on Trainor`s pub at Augenlig near Kilmore in Co
Armagh;
:: The murder of 33 people in UVF bomb attacks in Dublin
and Monaghan on May 17 1974;
:: The gunning down of three members of the Miami Showband
- 29-year-old lead singer Fran O`Toole, 23-year-old Anthony
Geraghty and 33-year-old trumpet player Brian McCoy - after
a UVF gang posing as an Ulster Defence Regiment patrol
flagged their bus down on July 31 1975.
The shootings took place after a bomb the UVF gang was
loading exploded prematurely as it was planted on the
band`s bus, killing the loyalist unit`s leader 24-year-old
Harris Boyle and his colleague 34-year-old Wesley
Somerville;
:: The shooting dead of six men - 24-year-old John Reavey,
his 22-year-old brother Brian and 17-year-old brother
Anthony and 24-year-old oil rig worker Barry O`Dowd, his
19-year-old brother Declan and his 61-year-old uncle Joe -
in separate UVF gun attacks on two families in Co Armagh on
January 4 1976;
:: The assassination of 49-year-old Catholic police
sergeant Joe Campbell by the UVF as he locked up the RUC
station in the Co Antrim seaside resort of Cushendall.
In only one case, the group was unable to reach a verdict
on collusion because of conflicting accounts - the murder
of 51-year-old driver James Marks and 78-year-old passenger
Joseph Toland in a gun attack in Gilford, Co Armagh, on a
minibus returning from bingo.
Among the witnesses they interviewed about security force
collusion with loyalists were former Army intelligence
officer Fred Holroyd, ex-civil servant Colin Wallace,
former RUC officers John Weir and Billy McCaughey.
The panel met representatives of three organisations
representing republican victims of violence - Families
Acting for Innocent Relatives, SAVER/NAVER, both in
Markethill, Co Armagh, and the WAVE Trauma Centre in
Belfast which caters for the victims of loyalist violence
too.
The cases examined in the Republic of Ireland include the
Dublin and Monaghan bombings, explosions in Dundalk and
Castleblayney and the murder of John Francis Green.
The study revealed it was told during its investigation
that the Garda failed to co-operate in bringing republicans
to justice for the murders of Protestants in the Republic.
The report said gardaí seized on technicalities to deny
extradition and "known criminals were allowed to roam
freely on the other side of the Border". They urged the
authorities in the Irish Republic to investigate the claims
made about their police.
The independent panel who produced the report were
Professor Douglass Cassel of Notre Dame Law School in the
US, Susie Kemp, an international lawyer based in The Hague,
Piers Pigou - an investigator for the South African Truth
and Reconciliation Commission and Stephen Sawyer of
Northwestern University School of Law.
Last year, the Irish government said it was to give Tony
Blair a final chance to aid an inquiry into the Dublin and
Monaghan bombings.
Irish premier Bertie Ahern said he may take a case to the
European Court of Human Rights if Mr Blair did not hand
over British government files on the 1974 bombings.
The UVF was suspected of carrying out the attacks which
killed 33 people. No-one was convicted of the bombings.